For nearly five months now I’ve been noodling around with the idea of creating a podcast. The idea is simple: take some of my existing essays, expand them out with deeper insight, behind-the-scenes musings, sections of the music in question, and end with a signature segment I’m calling The Six — that magical few seconds of any song that burns it permanently into your brain. There’s one major roadblock on this whole journey. It isn’t copyright. It isn’t fair use. It’s the system that polices them all — Content ID.
So before we go too much further, we’ve got to get into a touch of history — I’ll try and make it short, sweet, and to the point.
Napster was absolutely killing the record industry in the late ‘90s and early 2000s. But instead of taking down the music industry, it made record labels wake up to the power of what was in front of them — the full album as the means to the consumer end was largely dead. Folks wanted all of their music on their portable device (I was a massive fan of the MiniDisc format, but alas, Sony still hasn’t learned the Betamax lesson) and an easy way to get it — Napster filled that gap, and FOR FREE!
And boy howdy did the labels respond — an army of lawyers suing their way through a sea of copyright infringement. Only later did iTunes come along to offer a legal way to scratch the Napster itch. While the labels won the battle, the war was far from over, and they learned an incredibly valuable lesson: you can’t litigate a platform out of existence, so you co-opt it instead. Suppression doesn’t scale; control does.
Let’s fast-forward to 2005 or so, and YouTube is the new dumping ground for all manner of copyrighted material — music, movies, you name it. But the labels, they now know the score, and they go after the platform with a fury. Google buys YouTube in 2006 and immediately realizes their $1.65B acquisition is in serious trouble if they don’t come up with a solution. The hammer drops March 13, 2007, when Viacom, the owner of such properties as The Daily Show and South Park, sues Google. Viacom ultimately loses the lawsuit on a judgment in 2010, shielded by the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, with a settlement between the two in 2014.
But Google was already hot to trot, working on the problem. In June of 2007, Google launches Content ID as a shield against their lawsuit with Viacom as well as any future lawsuits. Now, the insidious part is in the details; this wasn’t Google acting alone to protect the intellectual property of big rights holders. In the room where this was being developed were Disney and Time Warner. Together they built an automated system that reached well beyond anything the law required of them — a machine that matches sound and nothing more, with no capacity to recognize fair use — letting rights holders find and either block or monetize their stuff, and suddenly Google isn’t a pirate den — it’s a partner handing the labels a money spigot.
Since it launched, Content ID has paid rights holders more than twelve billion dollars. Three billion in 2024 alone. In that same year, the system fired off 2.2 billion copyright claims — 99% of them automated, no human in the loop — and when the rights holders were given the choice of what to do with a flagged video, they chose the money more than ninety percent of the time. That’s the tell. A system sold as copyright protection, used overwhelmingly as a toll booth.
Now, the story often told by the music industry itself is that the system is designed to protect the artist — and who doesn’t want that? The best lies are filled with mostly truths. When a Content ID claim pays out, the money goes to the rights holder. And here’s the thing nobody says out loud: the rights holder often isn’t the artist. For major-label and catalog work, the money lands with the label or the publisher, and what trickles down to the musician depends entirely on a contract they probably signed years ago, frequently for pennies on the dollar, sometimes for nothing at all. The notable exception is the independent artist who owns her own masters — for her, the rights holder and the artist are the same person, and the claim really does pay her, assuming she’s a signatory to the program — we’ll hit that more later. But for the vast catalog that makes up the bulk of those billions, “compensating the artist” is a story the system tells about itself, not a thing you can assume is happening.
But all an indie artist who owns her own work needs to do is sign up for the program, right... RIGHT?! Again, another fantasy sold to the unsuspecting throngs of music fans. Call it artist-washing — the music-industry cousin of greenwashing: dressing a profit engine in the language of protecting the vulnerable party it actually bypasses.
Content ID access is deliberately, severely restricted. Per YouTube’s own reporting, it’s granted to roughly 7,700 “partners” — and YouTube’s own criteria say it’s for rights holders who hold “exclusive rights to a substantial body of original material” that’s frequently uploaded by the YouTube community. In plain terms: you have to already be big enough to have a catalog people are pirating before they’ll give you the tool to monetize the piracy. The independent artist — the one who owns her masters — is structurally the least likely to qualify. So what actually happens to her? She has two bad options: go through a distributor or a third-party rights-management company (who takes a cut, and who she has to trust to administer it honestly), or get nothing. Meanwhile, a label that administers any slice of her rights can claim, monetize, or block videos using her song — through a system she herself can’t access.
And that’s the rub of the whole “protect the artist” chicanery — the system itself is gated against the very artist who’d benefit most. Want to pour a little salt on that wound? At the same time the gate is closed, the system is weaponized against the small artist who can’t get her foot in the door, yet the big player can reach through the window and take her stuff.
That’s just one piece of this incredibly complex... puzzle? Scheme? Three-card monte? Like most creative endeavors, music exists as an ecosystem — the artist creates something that’s released onto the world, which is then absorbed into the broader culture. But it’s not a simple “I released this song, it’s now a chart-topping single, and we all go off to live happy lives.” Underneath all of that is a network of transmission lines, early adopters, concertgoers, music critics, playlist curators, TikTok influencers, and that really geeky person who takes two hours to tell you why a particular chord progression matters. This is where Content ID gets particularly onerous, as rights holders strangle their own marketing department to what amounts to pennies for the artist.
Let’s walk down another path for a second and look at the case of Rick Beato. Beato runs one of the largest music education channels on YouTube. I’m a massive fan of his videos that break down a song and explain exactly why it works, chord by chord, production choice by production choice. Over the course of nine years, Beato has faced more than 4,000 copyright claims, forcing him to choose between demonetizing the video and risking a copyright strike. Three copyright strikes filed against a creator, and the outlet is permanently deleted from the platform.
Pick a card, any card. Doesn’t matter — anyway, you lose.
In 2020, Beato testified before the U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary on DMCA limitations and fair use. Beato’s claim is that all of his use of the music falls into the fair use category and that Content ID goes far beyond any legal standard. The labels couldn’t have written a better system if they’d written it themselves. Oh, wait — they did. So, as written, Content ID flips the burden onto the content creator — guilty until you prove otherwise. And you don’t get to make that case in a courtroom, where fair use actually lives. You make it inside YouTube’s own system, to the very rights holder who filed the claim. The accuser gets to play judge, and the one venue where your fair-use argument would mean something is the one place the process never reaches. Meanwhile, that piece you just spent hours creating, telling the world why Portishead is the greatest band in the world, with examples? Blocked. This is the knife’s edge any creator who needs to use the music to make their point walks along. Put plainly, Content ID is an algorithm; it has no idea if your use of “Glory Box” is a full-on lift of the song or the six seconds used to explain the moment the song elevates itself. I’ll let Beato have the last word on that one.
“You need to play people’s music to talk about it. That is the definition of fair use.”
There’s that phrase again: fair use. But what exactly does it mean? Look, I’m not a lawyer, I don’t even play one on TV, so I’m going to go straight to the source here. As established in Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act, the law provides a statutory framework that identifies favored purposes and outlines a case-by-case balancing test. Those four favored purposes explicitly called out in the statute:
Criticism and comment
News reporting
Teaching
Scholarship and research
Someone want to explain to me how a brute-force algorithm makes that distinction?
Beato may be one of the more famous (and documented) creators fighting this fight, but he most certainly isn’t the only one. Here’s what the basic flow looks like: when Content ID flags a video, the rights holder picks one of three policies — block (video comes down/goes dark in chosen territories), track (stays up, no money changes hands, they just watch the numbers), or monetize (video stays up, ads run on it, and the ad revenue goes to the rights holder instead of the uploader). And we already know which one they pick — free money on a package someone else created.
And here’s where this turns back to me. Call me the collateral damage or the unintended consequence — either works. I want to be clear about something: I’m in no way against record labels making money. Along with my friends Jason and Jeremey, we ran a small book publishing company called Nightshade Books. I had a front-row seat into all aspects of the financials. I’m keenly aware that the company itself has to be able to survive if it’s going to publish the next book. The three of us always put the author first, and there were plenty of times when that philosophy nearly broke us. The question we were always asking ourselves is the question I would put back at the industry — how much is enough?
At what point does a machine built to capture every last dollar start doing more harm than good — not to a balance sheet, but to the thing the whole business depends on: people loving music enough to talk about it, share it, pass it hand to hand?
Let me try to make this tangible, because “Content ID” and “rights holders” and billions in ad revenue are the kind of words that slide right off a person. So picture the whole musical ecosystem as a hundred people in a room. I’m pulling these numbers out of thin air — don’t write me about the math — but roughly, here’s how I see it: five of those hundred are the artists making the music. Twenty or so are the label types. Fifteen are the music enthusiasts like me, out there championing songs and albums to anyone who’ll listen. And the other sixty? They’re the average listeners, taking in music however they please, giving no thought at all to the wizards behind the curtain.
Those sixty don’t come to music on their own — they come because one of the fifteen put it in front of them. The enthusiasts are the bridge to everybody else, and Content ID is charging a toll on that bridge until crossing it isn’t worth the trip. So how do you get the sixty to care? You don’t. Not if the people who’d make them care have been priced out of the conversation.
I mentioned at the top the possibility of starting a podcast to support and further the work I do on Playin’ in a Traveling Band. My intent was to start with audio-only, get comfortable there, and then move it to YouTube with video. In my mind, the podcast cannot be made without the inclusion of pieces of the songs I’m talking about. As I go further and further down this road, this whole idea of Content ID is staring into my soul deeper and deeper with every step I take. How does a newer-in-their-efforts creator even get started?
So here I sit, five months in, a microphone I haven’t turned on, an idea I can’t quite build — because the system that was supposedly made to protect the music can’t tell the difference between a man stealing a song and a man standing up to say, “God, listen to this — listen to what they did right here.” How does someone just starting out ever get off the ground? I honestly don’t know. But I think that’s exactly the question they’re counting on you not to ask.
Sources
Google’s acquisition of YouTube for $1.65 billion, announced October 9, 2006 — Google press release and contemporaneous reporting
Viacom International Inc. v. YouTube, Inc. — filed March 13, 2007 ($1 billion); dismissed June 23, 2010 on DMCA safe-harbor grounds; settled 2014 — Electronic Frontier Foundation
Content ID launched in 2007, initially tested with Time Warner and Disney — Reuters (June 2007)
Content ID payouts: more than $12 billion cumulative as of December 2024, $3 billion in 2024 (up from $9 billion at the end of 2023); 2.2 billion claims in 2024, 99% automated — RouteNote; YouTube “How Google Fights Piracy”
More than 90% of Content ID claims result in monetization — Google official blog, “Continuing to create value while fighting piracy”
Content ID eligibility criteria (”exclusive rights to a substantial body of original material…”) — YouTube Help
Fair use, 17 U.S.C. § 107 — Cornell Legal Information Institute
Rick Beato: roughly 4,000 claims over nine years; his Rick Rubin interview drew 13 separate claims; a 42-second Olivia Rodrigo video with about ten seconds of music was still claimed; 2020 Senate Judiciary testimony; 2025 UMG escalation from claims to strikes — TechSpot, Saving Country Music, The Honest Broker






Great round up of data and thought provoking. And I really hear you on this. There's no easy way to go. I heard Gavin Rossdale, Bush say he's no idea how his kids, who want to go into music, and are beginning/ trying are going to make a living.. how does anyone on music anymore? He said. And he's right. And his kids have 3 musician parents Gavin, Gwen Stefani and Blake Shelton lol So if they can't. Chris Cornell's daughters can't. So this resonates. I'll write my tale too sometime. I hope you figure it out.. I'll be watching you :)